Collection Explore
Essay
The Movement Unmasked
by Lisa Grady-Willis
2020 33 4 pr gal w01
info Created with Sketch. plus Created with Sketch.
Isaac Scott (born Quincy, Illinois, 1990)
June 8th, 2020. Juniper St and Filbert St, 2020
archival pigment print
The Jack Shear Collection of Photography at the Tang Teaching Museum
2020.33.4

Lisa Grady-Willis
Program Associate Director and Visiting Professor of Intergroup Relations
Skidmore College

We Wear the Mask(1)
By Paul Laurence Dunbar

We wear the mask that grins and lies,
It hides our cheeks and shades our eyes,— 
This debt we pay to human guile; 
With torn and bleeding hearts we smile, 
And mouth with myriad subtleties.

Why should the world be over-wise,
In counting all our tears and sighs? 
Nay, let them only see us, while 
We wear the mask.

We smile, but O great Christ, our cries
To thee from tortured souls arise.
We sing, but oh the clay is vile 
Beneath our feet, and long the mile;
But let the world dream otherwise, 
We wear the mask!

DSC04796.JPG
Masks made by MASKS4PEOPLE and Nicole Cherubini in Nicole Cherubini: Shaking the Trees, Tang Teaching Museum, 2020

Our masks are wearing thin …

In 1896, poet Paul Laurence Dunbar spoke of wearing the mask—the armor and protection necessary to shield our hearts from the rest of the world. He calls us to reckon with all that the mask represents and all that is hidden underneath. Today, the mask is no longer just a symbol or metaphor—it is also a physical reality donned by many who are unfamiliar with the purpose, power, and pain involved.

Both internal and external debates rage on regarding who, when, and why. Whom does it serve? When is it necessary? And just, why?

There are people deeply committed to the preservation of self, while some put other folks first, seeking to shield those around them from what intimate engagement might bring. Still others recognize preservation of self as a societal gateway beyond individual concerns. They see preservation of self as preservation of homeplace, family, and community. They see themselves as inextricably linked to those around them: individual survival is communal survival. Likewise, collective shifts require individual investment on a foundational level.

The need to breathe is ever-present while the fight to breathe persists—whether on the pavement or in the hospital room. Faces unadorned, we share spaces with those privileged to know what is behind the mask. “Torn and bleeding hearts” revealed—the fear, the frustration, and the pain that we share contributes to our interdependence. We take deep, measured breaths as we move about, behind shut doors, closed windows, and open computers. We are constantly strategizing about the next move and waiting for the next pronouncement. We hold our breath when a seal, a promise of security, is broken. We scramble to gather our thoughts and our things (sanitizer, mask, bullhorn, backpack …). Comfort falls by the wayside—even in our most sacred spaces.

Though die-ins, reenactments, and marches may offer some clarity, symbolic moments of solidarity cannot convey the solitary reality of face pressed to pavement … dignity undone.

I walked into the grocery store on Thursday, May 28, 2020, and was overcome by the reality of the day. Tears flowed slowly over my mask as I moved from aisle to aisle and heard folks exchanging pleasantries. I had stayed up through the night watching as things unfolded and buildings burned. No. I’m not okay. Are you?

Cite this page

Grady-Willis, Lisa. “The Movement Unmasked by Lisa Grady-Willis.” Tang Teaching Museum collections website. Last modified January 27, 2021. https://tang.skidmore.edu/collection/explore/258-the-movement-unmasked-by-lisa-grady-willis.

Learn more

Isaac Scott
Artist
MASKS4PEOPLE
Artist
Nicole Cherubini
Artist
Danielle St. Laurent
Artist
Convert?fit=crop&h=60&quality=95&w=60&compress=true&fit=crop
Pandemic and Protest
Exhibition
Convert?fit=crop&h=60&quality=95&w=60&compress=true&fit=crop
Nicole Cherubini: Shaking the Trees
Exhibition
2020 33 10 pr gal w01
June 1st, 2020. 22nd St and Benjamin Franklin Pkwy
Artwork
2020 33 7 pr gal w01
June 4th, 2020. Philadelphia Museum of Art Steps
Artwork
2020 33 4 pr gal w01
June 8th, 2020. Juniper St and Filbert St
Artwork
2020 33 2 pr gal w01
June 19th, 2020. Malcom X Memorial Park
Artwork
2020 49 2 pr w01
mask
Artwork
2020 49 4 pr w01 upside down
mask
Artwork
2020 49 7 pr w01
mask
Artwork
2020 48 1b gal
The Austin Family In Quarantine
Artwork
2020 48 3b gal
The Bhandari/Johnson Family In Quarantine
Artwork
2020 48 6b gal
The Oliverio/Kwan Family In Quarantine
Artwork
Convert?fit=crop&h=60&quality=95&w=60&compress=true&fit=crop
From Barrier to Bridge by Rachel Cantave
Essay
Convert?fit=crop&h=60&quality=95&w=60&compress=true&fit=crop
Nicole Cherubini and MASKS4PEOPLE on Experimentation and Community Building
Interview
Convert?fit=crop&h=60&quality=95&w=60&compress=true&fit=crop
Julia Routbort on MASKS4PEOPLE Masks
Essay
Convert?fit=crop&h=60&quality=95&w=60&compress=true&fit=crop
Danielle St. Laurent on Family Portraits in the Time of COVID-19
Interview
Convert?fit=crop&h=60&quality=95&w=60&compress=true&fit=crop
Kelli Johnson on Isaac Scott
Essay
Convert?fit=crop&h=60&quality=95&w=60&compress=true&fit=crop
Andrew Demaree on Isaac Scott
Essay
Convert?fit=crop&h=60&quality=95&w=60&compress=true&fit=crop
Cerri Banks on Pandemic and Protest
Essay
Convert?fit=crop&h=60&quality=95&w=60&compress=true&fit=crop
Isaac Scott on Documenting Protest in Philadelphia
Interview
i
Pattern as of May 6, 9:35:57 pm
on-campus page views today: 61
off-campus page views today: 50576
current wind in Saratoga Springs: 4.63 mph, NNW
Website design: Linked by Air